Last week we were in John 18. Couple of things I noticed. First, working through the text I kept finding myself in John 19. The two chapters seem to be better approached as a unit.
Second, there is more than one way to look at the content of the chapter but this time through what I notices was the contrast between Peter’s actions and attitudes and Jesus’ actions and attitudes. I used a matrix chart to compare and contrast them:
I am not thrilled with calling that first column “state” but that is the best I can do right now.
The contrast between Jesus and Peter emphasized for me the intentionality of Christ in obeying His Father in this act of redemption.
What do you see?
Second, there is more than one way to look at the content of the chapter but this time through what I notices was the contrast between Peter’s actions and attitudes and Jesus’ actions and attitudes. I used a matrix chart to compare and contrast them:
State | Jesus | Peter |
Awareness | Knew what was coming | Did not know what was coming |
Involvement | In Control | Out of Control |
Acceptance | Did not resist | Attacked with a Sword |
Obedience | Following His Father | Following his emotion/will |
Entrance | Brought in by Soldiers | Brought in by John |
Declaration | I am | I am not |
Confidence | Affirmed His identity | Denied his identity |
Captor | Bound by chains | Bound by Fear |
Inquisitor | Questioned by the High Priest and Pilate | Questioned by Slaves and Cold Soldiers |
Destination | Going to His death | Going to protect himself |
Immediate End Result | Crucifixion Honor | Out of the Story Shame |
Result | Success | Failure |
The contrast between Jesus and Peter emphasized for me the intentionality of Christ in obeying His Father in this act of redemption.
What do you see?
Great observations!
ReplyDeleteThanks, nothing you could not see for yourself...
DeleteContrast is often a powerful source of insight, and no more so than when contrasting man with God in some way. Checking the dictionary I found that "but" is one word indicating contrast.
ReplyDeleteI did a quick search in English in the Bible for "but." There were just a tad under 4000 hits.
Then I looked at John 17 and 18 specifically, and although the were 20 or so "buts" (maybe more), I really didn't see a correlation with what you listed.
So what is a potential lesson for the exercise in trivia? Perhaps that there are a whole lot more, maybe significant, contrasts than one word can express and it's not good to get too focused, short-sighted.
It will take me a while to sort those out; but obviously its a significant concept in Scripture.
Thanks, Mike.